Charlotte Tilbury's Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! mascara, launched in 2022, continues to capture the attention of beauty enthusiasts with its unique thickening formula and distinctive paddle-shaped brush. The brand's iconic "Pillow Talk" shade family has expanded to include this mascara, available in two shades: Super Black for a classic, bold look, and Dream Pop, a warm reddish-brown.
The mascara comes in classic, gorgeous Charlotte Tilbury packaging, featuring a soft metallic rose and embossed branding. It is described as lightweight and luxe.
Formula and Brush Performance
The mascara features a distinctive paddle-shaped brush, designed to lift and lengthen lashes. However, opinions on its effectiveness, particularly regarding curl and hold, are divided among users. One reviewer noted that even after curling her lashes, the mascara felt too wet to grip and lift effectively. This reviewer also experienced smudging due to oily skin, with the mascara starting to smudge slightly after just 30 minutes.
Other users have found the brush and formula to be effective when used as directed. User BozoInAMiniSkirt commented, "I found it decent if you follow the directions of using the flat side of the wand then the edges to lengthen."
Shade Range and "Pillow Talk" Confusion
The Pillow Talk Push Up Lashes! mascara is available in two shades:
- Super Black: For a classic, bold look.
- Dream Pop: A warm reddish-brown.
Some users have found the "Pillow Talk" branding to be slightly confusing, as it doesn't immediately evoke the typical mascara look. User ScaryPearls expressed, "This actually looks like a mascara I would really like. But I just can’t for the life of me figure out how this is Pillow Talk?" However, others, like the reviewer who is a self-proclaimed Charlotte Tilbury fan, understand the connection: "Personally, I’m not too bothered by the name! I get why it’s called Pillow Talk. It fits perfectly with the rest of the collection."
User Experiences and Value
Customer reviews are mixed. While some users, like Amb_31, state, "My favourite is the pillow talk push up lashes mascara," others have had less positive experiences. User Tedlovesme reported, "Smudgy as hell."
At £28/$29 for the full size, this mascara falls into the high-end price bracket. While the packaging and shade options are appealing, the formula's performance can vary significantly depending on individual lash and skin types. For those seeking a natural look, Glossier's Lash Slick is a preferred alternative, while Clinique High Impact is recommended for a more dramatic effect by one reviewer.