Elf All Nighter Setting Spray Reviews

In this comprehensive review, we delve into the entire current lineup of e.l.f. setting sprays, testing their performance on combination skin. Each spray in this packaging style features a fine mist and contains a ball at the bottom to ensure proper shaking and product dispersion.

e.l.f. Stay All Day Blue Light Micro-Setting Mist

This setting spray provides a matte finish and effectively sets the skin, significantly extending the wear time of makeup. A notable benefit is its lack of scent. While its ability to block blue light is difficult to ascertain, it does not negatively impact normal oil production. When used in conjunction with proper skincare and primer, this spray is considered excellent. It is deemed superior to the "Stay All Night" variant.

Claims: This spray is designed to set makeup and refresh it throughout the day. Glucosylrutin is included to reduce blue light emittance. The formula is lightweight, suitable for all skin types, and aims to provide a matte, shine-free finish.

Some users have reported issues with the spray nozzle clogging after a few uses. Although it contains a shaker ball, e.l.f. has reportedly addressed this issue. Similar to the blue light claim, this spray effectively sets makeup with a matte finish and prolongs wear time.

e.l.f. Matte Magic Mist & Set

This spray aims to provide up to 16 hours of wear with a lightweight formula. It imparts a subtle, fresh, and healthy glow without the use of shimmers or glitters. There is no shaker ball included. As with other sprays in this packaging, it features a fine mist and successfully sets makeup.

It is noted that this dewy mist results in more shine by the end of the day compared to other options, partly due to natural oils and partly due to the spray itself. Despite this, the appearance is considered pretty good for a dewy mist, even with some wear and tear.

Claims: This spray should hydrate and condition the skin for a long-lasting finish.

e.l.f. Makeup Mist & Set

This product is considered the original setting spray from e.l.f., with its history tracing back to the brand's early days. Initially offered in white packaging for the Essential line and black for the Studio line, trying it again years later yields impressive results.

This spray effectively sets makeup and extends wear time, though perhaps not as significantly as "Stay All Day" or "Stay All Night," as some wear and tear is visible. It is considered a nice daily option.

Claims: This spray should hold makeup in place all day, while also revitalizing, soothing, and hydrating the skin. It provides a basic, matte finish that is not drying. It is believed to extend makeup wear time, though with slightly more wear and tear compared to "Stay All Day" or "Stay All Night."

e.l.f. Dewy Coconut Setting Mist

This spray is lightweight and helps makeup last. It does not provide an illuminated or radiant look, but may offer a very subtle hint of fine glitter. The overall finish is matte.

Claims: This spray is lightweight and helps your makeup to last.

General Performance and User Experience

e.l.f. offers a range of setting sprays that are effective at extending makeup wear time. The brand provides options for dewy, matte, and natural finishes.

Overall Best Picks:

• Best Overall: Stay All Day Blue Light Micro-Setting Mist (matte finish, no scent, fine mist, excellent wear time).
• Best for Natural Finish: Makeup Mist & Set.
• Best for Dewy Skin: Dewy Coconut Setting Mist.

Most e.l.f. setting sprays do help extend makeup wear time, with the "Stay All Day" line showing the best results. Matte sprays are more effective at controlling shine throughout the day. All formulas tested featured a fine, even mist that applied smoothly without disturbing makeup.

Specific Product Performance Notes:

• The Stay All Day Blue Light Micro-Setting Mist is highly recommended for oily or combination skin due to its matte finish.
• The Dewy Coconut Setting Mist is great for those seeking a hydrated, radiant finish, though its longevity may be slightly less than matte options.
• The Makeup Mist & Set is a solid everyday option that effectively sets makeup.
• One variant, characterized by a strong smell, offers excellent staying power but may be overpowering for some.

Pros and Cons of e.l.f. Setting Sprays:

e.l.f. setting sprays offer many advantages, including affordability and effectiveness. However, some formulas contain fragrance, and certain options might leave a slight shine.

Who Should Use e.l.f. Setting Spray?

For individuals with oily skin, matte formulas are recommended to avoid enhancing shine. e.l.f. setting sprays are generally beginner-friendly due to their ease of use.

Ingredients (Example: Makeup Mist & Set):

Water (Aqua), Propylene Glycol, AMP-Acrylates/Allyl Methacrylate Copolymer, Glyceryl Acrylate/Acrylic Acid Copolymer, Glycerin, Coceth-7, PPG-1-PEG-9 Lauryl Glycol Ether, PEG-40 Hydrogenated Castor Oil, Retinyl Palmitate, Ascorbyl Palmitate, Tocopheryl Acetate, Camellia Sinensis Leaf Extract, Butylene Glycol, Disodium EDTA, Caprylyl Glycol, Phenoxyethanol.

User Testimonials:

• "Works really well. Kept my makeup nice for 10hrs straight. Just had to blot the excess oil. Makeup didn’t move."
• "Love the stay."
• "Just like the name my makeup stays all night."
• "The best there is nice product."
• "The best for all skin types."
• "It's a great setting spray; it melts down your makeup and helps it blend better, and once it dries, it stays on for a long time. This one is a great CT dupe as well; it's a must-try."
• "Nice setting spray for daily use…can give it a try."
• "Feels like expensive setting spray."
• "Amazing. Extremely fine spray and does make your makeup last long!"
• "It's a great setting spray! I love the fine mist, and it actually helps the makeup last longer. Love it!!"
• "Works amazing and long lasting."
• "It’s a very fine Mist good for summers."
• "Elf setting spray is the bong for the price and quality delivered."
• "Amazing! A must have product, go for it."
• "Doesn't cause breakouts. Non-comedogenic. While it did make the makeup look slightly oxidized, it provides a good finish. The final outcome may be one shade darker. Long-lasting."
• "Very dewy. I feel like it almost melts my makeup off."
• "It is not dewy or matte , it gives natural finish , helps to reduce powdery finish look n extend the wear time of makeup . Can Buy it in discount only."
• "The spray nozzle is amazing, it disperses the product into a fine mist that evenly applies on face. But i don't think it works well with aqualogica sunscreen, i use the green..."
• "I was slightly doubtful about the 16 hour claim since I don’t trust ELF a lot however this setting mist really does work! Amo, al aplicarlo no se siente cargado, me dura mi maquillaje, y me siento fresca con el. Es mi primer producto que compro de E.LF, y no me ha decepcionado.The best product for sealing makeup, it does not feel heavy, it is light and refreshing, I love it. Perfect for my sensitive oily skin, the finish is beautiful.I personally didn’t really enjoy this one. I think it’s a great product, but it felt like it was leaving me more oily and cakey. Still a great product."

When considering the "Makeup Mist & Set," it is often compared to MAC's Fix Plus. This e.l.f. product aims to combat humidity and sebum that can cause makeup to run. The application results in a wet sensation that takes time to dry, but once dry, it feels natural and comfortable with a finish between dewy and matte. It also enhances eyeshadow pigment application.

tags: #elf #all #night #setting #spray