Mascara is a quintessential beauty product, transforming eyes from tired to vibrant with just a few coats. For many, it's an indispensable part of their makeup routine, enhancing lashes to make eyes pop. This article delves into a comprehensive review of various mascaras, with a particular focus on the Covergirl LashBlast Length mascara, exploring their performance in terms of volume, length, clumping, flaking, and longevity. The reviews are based on personal testing by the author and a colleague, Lauren, who tested both regular and waterproof formulas over nine consecutive days.
Understanding Mascara Preferences
The author expresses a strong preference for mascaras that deliver significant volume and length, aiming for a dramatic enhancement of the eyes. Key factors in evaluating mascaras include their ability to provide volume, length, and width, while avoiding undesirable effects such as clumping, flaking, and messiness. The article aims to guide readers in choosing mascaras that are worth purchasing and those that are best avoided.
Mascara Reviews: A Detailed Breakdown
The following reviews cover a range of mascaras, presenting both the author's and Lauren's findings for regular and waterproof formulas, respectively. Each mascara is assessed based on its performance and user experience.
Maybelline Lash Sensational
This mascara, priced under $10, was a strong contender for the top pick. The author appreciated its curved wand, excellent lengthening capabilities, and sufficient volume without significant clumping or flaking. However, while one coat offers a subtle effect, multiple coats can quickly lead to clumping. The waterproof version was noted for its superior hold, resisting tears, showers, and face wash.
Lancome Monsieur Big
At $25, this mascara is lauded for delivering exceptional volume and length, potentially the most among the tested products. It applied with a feel akin to fiber lashes. Despite the author initially feeling a "spider-like" appearance, Lauren selected this as her favorite, with her accompanying photos showcasing impressive lash results. The author noted that a faster application between coats is necessary to prevent clumping.
Covergirl LashBlast Volume
Priced under $10, this mascara scored highly on paper for its performance. While it excels in not flaking or clumping (noted as the best in this regard) and provides significant length, it was not the author's daily go-to due to a perceived lack of "oomph" in volume. The application was smooth, with noticeable impact after the third coat. The waterproof version proved exceptionally difficult to remove, requiring a more intense eye makeup remover.
L'Oreal Voluminous Lash Paradise
This mascara, also under $10, is often cited as a dupe for "Better Than Sex" mascara. The author preferred it over its more expensive counterpart, finding it effective for both volume and length. A minor complaint was slight flaking during application. One coat provided a noticeable difference, but two coats quickly became clumpy, necessitating the use of a lash separator to achieve an even finish.
Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes
This $23 mascara impressed with its packaging and its ability to add significant length without clumping. However, it had a longer drying time. One coat yielded impressive results, though it was initially a bit clumpy, which seemed to even out with subsequent coats. The drying time was noted as a slight drawback.
L'Oreal Voluminous Black
While not the author's favorite, this mascara under $10 performed adequately. It applied with a noticeably "wet" consistency, leaving marks on the skin during application. It provided good lengthening but lacked the desired volume. The appearance improved significantly after three coats, adding both volume and length without clumping.
Too Faced Better Than Sex
This $24 mascara, while initially loved, was found to flake significantly throughout the day. It also tended to clump upon initial application, requiring caution even with a single coat.
Pacifica Aquarian Glaze (Vegan)
Priced under $10, this vegan mascara was met with a humorous critique from the author's husband regarding its appearance. It clumped significantly and had a very wet consistency. The comb-style brush was appreciated, and it applied smoothly without clumping. However, it was not truly waterproof, washing off almost completely in the shower, though it might withstand a workout.
Clinique High Impact Mascara
This $19 mascara received the lowest rating. While one coat added length but little volume, three coats still did not significantly increase volume. However, it was praised for not clumping at all.
Deep Dive into the Covergirl LashBlast Collection
Covergirl mascaras have been a long-standing part of the author's makeup collection, with a particular fondness for the LashBlast collection. The article then provides a more detailed look at specific mascaras within this line:
- LashBlast Volume (Orange): Recommended for everyday wear, offering full lash coverage without clumps and a non-dramatic finish. Ideal for simple makeup looks for errands or work.
- LashBlast Fusion (Purple): A step up for added drama, featuring a plump brush that provides significant volume and makes lashes stand out.
- LashBlast Length (Yellow): While the author is not the biggest fan, it delivers on its promise of lengthening lashes from corner to corner with its thin, long brush. However, the thin brush may result in less coverage than desired.
- LashBlast Clump Crusher (Green): Hailed as the author's favorite, offering perfect color and coverage with a dramatic pop. It's ideal for accompanying thick, dark liner and provides excellent fanning of lashes from corner to corner, complemented by a curved brush for easy application in corners.
- LashBlast Luxe (Pink): Not yet tried by the author, but expected to be a good product based on past experiences with the collection.
The LashBlast Collection is presented as the best drugstore mascara option, negating the need to spend a lot on designer brands.
Expert and Consumer Insights on Top Mascaras
The article incorporates findings from Good Housekeeping's testing, providing further insights into various mascaras:
Maybelline Lash Sensational Waterproof Mascara
- Pros: Budget-friendly, curls, lifts, and lengthens lashes; applies smoothly without flaking. Earned high satisfaction scores, with testers rating it best for creating the desired look. The curved wand was particularly effective for curling, eliminating the need for a separate curler. Scored highly for lifting, volumizing, and thickening.
- Formula: Scored highly for resisting flakes and smooth application with an easy-to-use brush, though it has a tendency to clump.
- Waterproofness: Rated 100% for resisting smudges and perfect scores for resisting running when exposed to water. It withstood naps, swimming, humidity, and showers.
Maybelline Great Lash Waterproof Mascara
- Pros: Budget-friendly, flake-free in Beauty Lab tests, smooth application.
- Cons: Doesn't add much volume; difficult to remove.
- Benefits: Praised for resisting smudging and its easy-to-use brush. Testers noted it held a curl well and made lashes look longer and more defined without much effort, though it's not very volumizing and doesn't separate lashes as well as other wands.
- Formula: Applied smoothly without clumping or flaking throughout the day.
- Waterproofness: Lasts all day without smudging or flaking, even in humid weather, though it can be difficult to remove.
Maybelline Lash Sensational Sky High Waterproof Mascara
- Pros: Budget-friendly, smooth, clump-free application, adds lift and volume.
- Cons: May not be best for curling.
- Benefits: Reviewers noted its excellent lengthening effect, making lashes appear like false lashes. The buildable formula adds volume and length. A slight wish for longer-lasting curl was mentioned.
- Formula: Applied smoothly without clumps and wore without smudging. The brush with small rubbery bristles separates and lengthens lashes without stiffness.
- Waterproofness: Stays put without smudging or running, even through tears and humidity. Easy to remove at the end of the day.
Maybelline New York Volum' Express The Colossal Waterproof Mascara
- Pros: Budget-friendly, volumizing and lengthening, non-irritating and easy to use.
- Benefits: Provides good volume and length without flaking. The brush is easy to use, even with short bristles and a wide wand diameter.
- Formula: Applied smoothly, even through multiple applications, without clumping. Perfect scores for being non-irritating.
- Waterproofness: Earned a perfect score for not running when exposed to water, ideal for long days or swimming. Lasts without smudging, even on oily lids, though it can be tough to remove.
CoverGirl LashBlast Volume Waterproof Mascara
- Pros: Reviewer favorite for long-lasting, flake-free results; budget-friendly.
- Cons: Could be more volumizing.
- Benefits: Great for both volumizing and lengthening with a dark, intense black shade. The wand coats and separates lashes with minimal clumping.
- Formula: Lasts longer than other mascaras without flaking. The brush has fluffy fibers that grab lashes well.
- Waterproofness: Stays put through various conditions, described as able to withstand significant water exposure.
Maybelline New York Volum' Express The Colossal Spider Effect Waterproof Mascara
- Pros: Top Beauty Lab scores for resisting smudges; separates and fans lashes well.
- Cons: Poor score for lengthening lashes.
- Benefits: The unique helix-shaped rubber wand separates and fans lashes effectively. Multiple coats may be needed for desired volume, and it received poor scores for lengthening.
- Formula: Non-irritating with a pleasant scent, suitable for sensitive skin. The brush applicator is easy to use.
- Waterproofness: Earned the highest scores for resisting smudges, smears, and runs. Noted as potentially difficult to remove.
Covergirl LashBlast Length Mascara
- Pros: Buildable, lengthening formula; curved wand for easy application; budget-friendly.
- Cons: Natural look may not suit some; potentially stiff and scratchy brush; difficult to layer.
- Benefits: Makes lashes look fuller. The varying bristle lengths help lift lashes. The curved brush shape aids in reaching all lashes.
- Formula: Stays on all day, does not flake, and removes easily with makeup wipes. Creates a wispy, natural look rather than thick or dramatic lashes.
- Waterproofness: Described as "island-proof," lasting through humidity, sweat, beach days, and rain without smudging, flaking, or running. Holds up through tears.
Covergirl Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara
- Pros: Top scores for volumizing and thickening lashes; budget-friendly.
- Cons: Prone to smudging and flaking.
- Benefits: Rated best for volumizing and thickening, with testers noting ease of coating all lashes for longer, fuller appearance.
- Formula: A little sticky but easy to build upon and dries slowly. Makes lashes look thicker and darker.
- Waterproofness: Perfect score for not running when exposed to water, but this ease of removal contributes to potential flaking and smudging.
Tarte Lights, Camera, Lashes 4-in-1 Mascara
- Pros: Top Beauty Lab scores for separating and lengthening lashes; smooth, clump-free, and water-resistant application.
- Cons: Pricey; very difficult to remove.
- Benefits: Offers impressive volumizing results. Testers found the brush easy to use, with smooth, clump-free application and high impact in one coat. Received high scores for being non-irritating.
- Formula: Smooth, clump-free application.
- Waterproofness: Received high scores for water-resistance, though some testers noted smudging and rated it difficult to remove.
The Science Behind Waterproof Mascara
How Waterproof Mascara Differs from Regular Mascara
Waterproof mascaras generally offer superior performance in keeping lashes lifted and curled. They contain ingredients such as synthetic waxes, silicone, and film-forming agents that create a water-resistant barrier. This barrier helps the mascara adhere better to lashes and resist removal by water, sweat, or tears. While these robust additions can make the formula feel heavier, they are key to maintaining lift and curl.
Is It Okay to Wear Waterproof Mascara Every Day?
It is generally advised to reserve waterproof mascara for special occasions. Due to their strong adherence, waterproof formulas can lead to lash breakage or loss during removal if not done carefully. The harsher solvents required for removal, coupled with pulling and rubbing, can cause lashes to fall out and potentially irritate the delicate skin around the eyes over time. For regular wearers, it's recommended to use waterproof mascara up to three times a week, opting for regular formulas or going without mascara on other days to allow lashes a break.
What's the Best Way to Remove Waterproof Mascara?
Removing waterproof mascara effectively and gently is crucial. It's recommended to use a gentle eye makeup remover specifically formulated for waterproof cosmetics, such as Neutrogena Oil-Free Eye Makeup Remover. Ensure lashes are thoroughly saturated with the remover before swiping downwards and away. Holding a cotton pad soaked in remover on the eye for a few seconds before swiping can help break down the formula. Using a Q-tip saturated in makeup remover can also help clean mascara from between lashes, preventing morning smudges.
Testing Methodology
The Good Housekeeping Beauty Lab employs a rigorous testing process for makeup products. For waterproof mascaras, this includes evaluating thousands of products and conducting consumer at-home studies with over 130 testers. Key evaluation criteria include ease of use, performance (volumizing, curling, defining, thickening), wear (flaking, running, smudging), and ease of removal. Lab tests involve applying a controlled amount of product, allowing it to dry, and then exposing it to water to assess its resistance to smearing and running. Past tests have utilized VISIA imaging for objective measurement of lengthening and volumizing effects.
Tips From a Makeup Artist : Home Remedy for How to Remove Waterproof Mascara
Personal Experience with Covergirl Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara
A personal account highlights the impressive volume provided by Covergirl Lash Blast Clean Volume Mascara, even with cleaner formulations. One coat was sufficient for some, while two coats provided the desired height. The application was smooth, without the gloopiness sometimes found in clean mascaras. The bristles effectively grabbed each hair, and the mascara felt light. Notably, after a full day of wear, including accidental eye rubbing, no flakes or smudging were observed. The author expressed pleasant surprise and recommended this mascara for both clean beauty newcomers and pros.
Review of Covergirl LashBlast Length Mascara
The author's experience with Covergirl LashBlast Length mascara, specifically the yellow tube, is detailed. The bright, telescope-shaped packaging is easy to spot. The formula is described as a true black, clump-free, and neither too thick nor too runny. It applies quickly for natural, feathery lashes and offers no fading or flaking throughout the day, with no smudging or transfer even on oily lids. The separating and defining brush is a highlight. However, the lengthening effect is subtle, with absolutely no volumizing action. The mascara does not seem to hold a curl well, and the brush can feel a bit stiff and scratchy. Layering is also difficult, with two generous layers being applied in the photos. Ultimately, while the author acknowledges it's a good product, they prefer the Volume version and found L'Oreal Telescopic to be a better lengthening mascara due to its layering potential.
